Kuwait Press Memory Latest news
alwasatGeneral News

Absolute and Relative Nullity

Absolute and Relative Nullity
Alqyas summary

Criticism over lack of equal legal protection for contractors and difficulty in proving rights

Translated by Alqyas from Al-Wasat — Original source

The distinction between absolute nullity and relative nullity invites genuine criticism when legal protection yields uneven effects for the contracting parties. It is unacceptable for a person who has been defrauded to be forced to initiate judicial proceedings to annul a contract whose consent was vitiated by a defect, while the contract continues to produce its effects until a court rules it nullified. For example, if a person buys a car after the seller deliberately concealed a serious defect, the buyer may bear the burden of proving fraud and the costs of asserting his rights, even though he is the injured party.

The flaw that warrants criticism here is that legal protection may lose its effectiveness when accessing one’s right becomes more difficult than committing the violation; a right that is hard for its holder to prove and recover lacks practical value. Conversely, a contract that contravenes public order cannot be deemed valid merely because the parties consent to it, since their will cannot override the law. Therefore, the success of these rules should not be measured merely by distinguishing between the two types of nullity, but by ensuring that procedural hurdles or evidentiary difficulties do not become a means by which the wrongdoer benefits at the expense of the injured party.

Ghala Ali Al-Anazi

College of Commercial Studies / Law Major

Latest news Original source Kuwait's top news today
Link copied ✓