'Appeals' court upholds cancellation of transfer of employee at 'Commerce'... and returns her to her supervisory post
The Appeals Court upheld the cancellation of the transfer decision of an employee at the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, considering the decision a disguised administrative punishment.
Translated by Alqyas from Al-Seyassah — Original source
The Court of Appeal established a legal precedent regarding employee transfer controls, affirming that the administration’s authority to transfer staff is not absolute. It ruled that transfer decisions must be based on the exigencies of work interests and must not be used as a means to punish or retaliate against employees.
The court upheld a ruling by the Court of First Instance annulling a decision by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry to transfer an employee from the position of Head of the Appointments Department to the Preservation Department, along with all resulting consequences, primarily her reinstatement to her previous supervisory role with the same rank.
The lawyer Ali Al-Ali, acting as the employee’s representative, filed the lawsuit seeking to annul Administrative Decision No. 1591 of 2024. He stated that his client joined the ministry in 2007 and progressed professionally until she assumed the role of Head of the Appointments Department, prior to the issuance of the decision transferring her to another department that did not offer the same supervisory level.
Al-Ali argued that the contested decision did not serve work interests but rather constituted a disguised administrative penalty and infringed upon her acquired professional status, particularly given previous judicial rulings that annulled her performance evaluations for the years 2022 and 2023.
In its reasoning, the court emphasized that administrative transfers must be to an equivalent position in terms of rank, nature of work, and professional level. It stated that issuing a transfer with the intent to harm or retaliate against an employee effectively makes it a concealed disciplinary sanction, rather than a transfer necessitated by work interests.
The court noted that the administrative authority failed to provide evidence that the position to which the employee was transferred maintained the same supervisory level. Furthermore, the file lacked proof that the legal procedures prescribed for disciplining employees had been followed, thereby depriving the decision of its legal basis and rendering it legally flawed.
The court concluded by annulling the decision and reinstating the employee to her previous position, while ordering the administrative authority to bear court costs and 100 Kuwaiti Dinars for actual legal fees. The Court of Appeal upheld this judgment, reaffirming that the power of administrative transfer cannot be used to undermine acquired professional positions.