Kuwait Press Memory Latest news
alraiForeign Affairs By Elijah J. Magnier

Why Do Palestinian Citizens in Israel Remain Outside the Power Struggle?

Why Do Palestinian Citizens in Israel Remain Outside the Power Struggle?
Alqyas summary

Report on discrimination against Arab citizens in Israeli politics

Translated by Alqyas from Al-Rai — Original source

- The Arab Past of Israel’s Jewish Political Elite

- From Political Exclusion to Religious Justifications for Expulsion and Violence

The dispute remains ongoing between Gadi Eisenkot, tasked with forming the next Israeli government, and outgoing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, regarding who should lead the country. Nevertheless, both political camps have shown reluctance to include Arab-led parties in governing arrangements.

The two Arab lists won 19 seats in the 120-member Knesset, granting their elected representatives considerable parliamentary weight, despite remaining as separate political entities. Despite their electoral representation, their participation in the government has been met with rejection, amid accusations of extremism or alleged ties to terrorism.

This ongoing debate raises a fundamental question: Why are Israeli citizens of Palestinian-Arab descent—whether Muslim or Christian—often treated as unacceptable political partners, while Jewish politicians whose families originate from Arab countries are considered legitimate representatives of the state?

This conflict is not limited to government coalition calculations; it reveals conflicting definitions of who belongs to the Israeli political community and who is entitled to exercise governmental power.

This debate took a more troubling institutional turn on November 15, when an investigation by the Israeli television program “Uvda” revealed suspicions that Netanyahu’s office contributed to fabricating claims of election fraud, which were later used to cast doubt on Arab voters.

According to the investigation, Netanyahu’s office director, Edo Nordin, directed police toward information provided by a former staff member in the Prime Minister’s office, leading to the arrest of three activists from the United Arab List (Ra’am) on the morning of the election on October 27. All three were later released without any charges being filed, while Netanyahu exploited those arrests to claim that Arab parties had stolen votes.

In a separate development, reports indicated that Shabak (Israel Security Agency) official David Zini requested permission to wiretap five Arab parliamentarians on the grounds of foreign interference in the elections, a request that was rejected by the Attorney General’s Office.

Investigators have not yet determined whether these actions were part of a coordinated political process, while Netanyahu’s office denies committing any wrongdoing.

Nevertheless, these facts raise a question that goes beyond the issue of the legitimacy of Arab political participation: Were state security agencies and law enforcement institutions co-opted in efforts to undermine the electoral choices of Israeli citizens simply because those votes posed a threat to the ruling majority?

Israel’s political lexicon reflects this disparity; Palestinian citizens are routinely referred to as “Arabs,” even though their Israeli citizenship is indisputable. In contrast, Jewish citizens—including those whose families lived for generations in Baghdad, Damascus, Sana’a, Fes, or Marrakesh—are simply defined as “Israelis.”

Many of them are categorized as “Mizrahim” (Eastern Jews), a label that emphasizes their Jewish identity and geographical origins, while largely erasing their Arabic language and cultural heritage derived from their ancestors. Thus, one population group is defined by its ethnic or linguistic background, while the other is primarily defined by its national affiliation, regardless of its historical origins.

This contradiction takes on special significance when examined in light of Israel’s foundational legal principles. The 1948 Declaration of Independence guarantees full equality in social and political rights for all citizens, without discrimination on the basis of religion, race, or gender, and calls on the Arab population to participate in building the state through equal citizenship and representation.

However, the Basic Law: Israel as the Nation-State of the Jewish People, enacted in 2018, restricts the right to national self-determination exclusively to the Jewish people.

Although these texts address different legal dimensions, together they reveal an underlying tension between individual citizenship and the state’s collective national character.

This raises a fundamental question: Can equal political rights attain their full meaning in a reality where citizens can elect representatives, yet those representatives face obstacles to participating in governance—not because of their political positions, but based on their collective identity?

This discrimination does not mean that Palestinian citizens cease to be Arab simply because they hold Israeli identity cards, nor does it imply that Israeli Jews of Middle Eastern or North African origin must define themselves as Arab; identities are determined by individuals and communities themselves.

Historically, however, Arab-speaking Jewish groups were active participants in the social, cultural, and economic life of many Middle Eastern and North African societies, long before the establishment of Israel.

In 1948, Jews immigrated to Israel. Their integration into Israeli society altered their political and national affiliations, without erasing the historical ties from which their communities emerged.

The biographies of prominent Israeli figures embody these ties. Former Chief of Staff of the Israel Defense Forces Gadi Eisenkot was born to parents who immigrated from Morocco. Former minister and former Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana descends from a family of Moroccan origin. Arieh Deri, a politician from the Shas party who has held several ministerial positions, was born in Meknes, Morocco.

These family backgrounds do not determine the identity of the individuals concerned, but they demonstrate the deep-rooted connections between segments of Israel’s political establishment and communities typically described as belonging to the Arab world.

Moroccan Judaism cannot be reduced to a single origin. Some Jewish communities in North Africa existed before the arrival of Jews expelled from Spain and Portugal, while others descended from these Sephardic migrants. Over generations, religious practices, languages, and local customs interacted.

Moroccan Jews are often classified as Sephardim according to their religious traditions, and as Mizrahim within broader Israeli social categories, even though Morocco is geographically part of North Africa, not the Middle East. Neither of these classifications fully reflects the historical diversity of these communities.

The Mizrahi category also includes Jews originating from Iraq, Iran, Yemen, Syria, and other countries, whose historical experiences were highly varied. Some belong to Arabic-speaking communities, while others speak Persian or other regional languages.

This classification has gained significance in Israeli society, particularly when discussing the shared experiences of Jewish immigrants from non-European backgrounds, including discrimination and unequal opportunities. Nevertheless, their distinct cultural history remains of considerable importance.

The twentieth century radically transformed these relations through war, persecution, political unrest, Zionism, migration, and displacement. Jewish migrations from Middle Eastern and North African countries occurred under varying circumstances and cannot be attributed to a single cause.

Acknowledging earlier periods of cultural interaction does not imply ignoring hostility or coercion. Similarly, disruptions associated with the Arab-Israeli conflict should not obscure the centuries during which Jewish communities participated in the societies from which they eventually migrated.

For Palestinian citizens of Israel, the term “Arab” carries a different political connotation. Some identify primarily as Palestinian, while others use descriptors such as “Palestinian citizen of Israel” or “Arab citizen of Israel,” depending on their personal, national, and communal affiliations.

General and administrative classifications do not necessarily reflect these preferences. While the term “Arab” may accurately denote a linguistic or cultural identity, its political use can also distinguish Palestinian citizens from the national community implicitly represented by the term “Israeli.” Thus, the issue is not the legitimacy of Arab identity, but the conditions that make this identity more politically salient than citizenship.

Legal distinctions are also significant. Many Palestinians in East Jerusalem hold permanent residency rather than Israeli citizenship, while Muslim, Christian, Druze, and other communities differ in their histories, affiliations, and relationships with state institutions.

These population groups cannot be treated as socially or legally identical. However, religious affiliation or ethnic origin does not negate the right to vote, run for office, or participate in parliamentary life among holders of Israeli citizenship. The gap between possessing these rights and being accepted as a potential partner in governance raises questions about the practical limits of political integration.

Beyond disputes over parliamentary participation, a more radical current within religious-nationalist discourse has advocated for the expulsion of Arabs or justified violence against non-Jews based on specific interpretations of Jewish law.

Meir Kahana, founder of the Jewish Defense League and the Kach party, held a seat in the Knesset while openly calling for the expulsion of Arabs from Israel. He stated that if he became prime minister, no Arab would be killed in Israel, because none would remain in the country.

His stance was not merely opposition to Palestinian nationalism, but a rejection of the presence of Arabs within the state he envisioned.

Rabbi Dov Lior, former chief rabbi of the Kiryat Arba settlement, adopted a similar position; he called for the expulsion of Arabs from the country and their resettlement elsewhere, portraying their continued presence as an obstacle to peace. Such statements treated an entire population as “the problem,” rather than distinguishing citizens based on their individual political beliefs or personal conduct.

Religious arguments justifying the killing of non-Jews have also appeared in published rabbinic writings. Rabbis Yitzhak Shapira and Yosef Elitzur, associated with the “Otzma Yehudit” religious school in the West Bank settlement of Itzhar, authored a book titled “Torat HaMelekh” (The King’s Torah).

The book discussed circumstances that its authors considered permissible for killing non-Jews under Jewish law, including cases involving civilians and children. Their argument extended beyond combatants to include situations where harming innocent individuals from the “enemy” ranks might serve military objectives.

In the same year, in response to a question from Moment magazine about how Jews interact with their Arab neighbors, Rabbi Manis Friedman—associated with the Chabad movement and the Beit Hana Institute—rejected traditional restrictions that prohibit attacks on civilians and religious sites. He argued that war, according to his interpretation of Jewish law, could involve killing men, women, and children, as well as destroying places of worship.

The circulation of such interpretations within religious institutions linked to military preparation raises concerns of a different kind. In a recorded lecture accessed by Israeli journalist Yossi Gurvitz in 2018, Rabbi Ofer Wallas—of the Bnei David religious academy, which prepares students for military service—discussed interpretations of Jewish law that might permit the destruction of an entire enemy community.

According to the published translation, Wallas noted that the risk of international backlash and its potential consequences for Israel constitute crucial practical constraints.

For his part, Rabbi Eliyahu Mali—head of the Shirat Moshe religious school (yeshiva) in Jaffa, which combines religious study with military service—cited biblical texts, arguing that the threat is not limited solely to armed combatants but extends to children who may become fighters in the future, and to women who will bear those children.

This phenomenon is not confined to religious figures distant from partisan politics; Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, the former spiritual leader of the Shas party, made statements during a Passover sermon calling for the destruction of Arabs and inciting the use of rockets against them.

These examples indicate that Jews in Israel, or the Israeli government, embrace such interpretations; and they show that calls for mass expulsion and the practice of violence have been voiced by figures holding diverse positions within religious, educational, and political institutions.

At its core, the issue revolves around the practical meaning of citizenship in a polity that does not grant equal political legitimacy to all who hold that citizenship. While statements by some religious figures calling for expulsion or violence reveal one extreme side of the debate, the repeated resistance to Arab participation in government reveals another dimension, this time institutional. Israeli democratic institutions face a fundamental test: Will elected representatives be judged based on their political positions and conduct, or will their collective identity determine the ceiling of their participation?

The answer will reveal whether citizenship guarantees equal access to political legitimacy, or whether it is limited to merely conferring the formal right to participate in elections.

Latest news Original source Kuwait's top news today
Link copied ✓