Kuwait Press Memory Latest news
alqabasWriters & Opinion By Adnan Abdullah Al-Othman

Rental law between socialism and capitalism (2)

Rental law between socialism and capitalism (2)
Alqyas summary

The author analyzes the Kuwaiti rental law, highlighting its balance, and suggests linking the legitimacy of contracts to the legitimacy of units to avoid construction violations.

Translated by Alqyas from Al-Qabas — Original source

In our previous article, we discussed the relationship between rental laws and socialist and capitalist ideologies, examining the experiences of several countries that attempted to protect tenants from rising rents but faced challenges regarding landlords’ rights, the continuity of real estate investment, and the provision of housing. Today, we return to Kuwait, where I believe the Kuwaiti legislator has addressed many of the loopholes that plagued other countries’ experiences, achieving a reasonable degree of justice and balance between landlords and tenants. Kuwaiti Rental Law No. 35 of 1978, along with its amendments, does not leave tenants at the mercy of landlords, nor does it turn the lease contract into an eternal restriction on property ownership. It grants tenants protection against arbitrary eviction, while simultaneously allowing for rent review after five years, in accordance with legal regulations that consider the rents of comparable properties. Thus, it does not leave the rental value hostage to time and inflation indefinitely.

The legislator did not overlook the importance of renewing the housing stock; it permitted the eviction of old properties for demolition and reconstruction under specific conditions related to the building’s age (not less than 25 years), permits, and the size of the new construction, while providing guarantees for tenants and compensation in cases stipulated by law. This is a point worth noting: rebuilding an old building does not necessarily benefit the landlord alone; it may also mean increasing the number of rental units, improving the standard of buildings and services, and contributing to meeting the growing demand for housing. In this way, both economic and social interests are achieved.

However, in my view, this law lacks an important legislative treatment that I have previously written and spoken about: the absence of an explicit link between the rental law and the municipal laws governing construction and its violations. The problem begins when a construction violation is committed in an investment or commercial property, and the non-compliant unit is rented out under a contract protected by the provisions of the rental law. When the municipality discovers the violation, it demands that the property owner remove it within a specified period, potentially imposing heavy financial fines. This is where the paradox begins! The owner who wishes to rectify his violation and comply with the municipality’s decision may encounter a tenant occupying the non-compliant unit, who clings to the lease contract. Meanwhile, the rental law does not include an independent and explicit ground for eviction solely because the rented unit violates construction laws, a fact confirmed by judicial rulings. Consequently, the owner finds himself caught between a law requiring him to remove the violation and another law that may hinder his ability to evict the occupant necessary to carry out the demolition. The violation may persist, fines may accumulate, while the solution remains suspended between procedures and judicial disputes.

I am not advocating for construction violations, nor am I seeking a way out that exempts their perpetrators from responsibility; on the contrary, it is the state’s duty to enforce respect for construction laws, and it is the owner’s duty to rectify his violation and bear its consequences. But how can we demand that he remove the violation if we do not provide him with the legal means to do so? Hence, I renew my previous proposal to add a clear and definitive provision to the rental law stating: “No lease contract shall be recognized for any rental unit that violates construction laws.” In my opinion, this provision links the legitimacy of the rental relationship to the legitimacy of the rented unit itself. A construction violation should not become a permanent reality protected by lease contracts, nor should the contract become a means to obstruct municipal decisions.

Al-Wari argues that this addition will serve as a lifeline for anyone wishing to rectify their violation and return to compliance with the law, while simultaneously providing the state with a more effective tool for regulating the real estate market and encouraging landlords to verify the legality of units before offering them for rent. A legitimate question may arise here: What about the good-faith tenant who rented a unit unaware that it was non-compliant? I believe that protecting the tenant from harm is beyond dispute, but this should not mean allowing the continued occupation of a unit that violates the law. The tenant’s right to seek recourse against the landlord and claim compensation, when the grounds exist, is a matter distinct from the legality of continuing occupation. More importantly, this amendment will not benefit landlords alone; it will curb the renting of non-compliant units, encourage the regularization of real estate properties, and enhance the municipality’s capacity to fulfill its role in regulating urban development and safeguarding the public interest. In my view, the Kuwaiti legislator has succeeded in achieving a reasonable balance between the rights of landlords and tenants. However, legislation, no matter how precise, remains in need of review and development whenever practical experience reveals loopholes or inconsistencies in application. The law does not operate in isolation, but within a legislative framework whose provisions are expected to complement one another, rather than having the implementation of one stalled due to protections afforded by another law. Ultimately, this is not a victory of capitalism over socialism, nor of the landlord over the tenant, but a triumph of the rule of law and the achievement of justice for all. A lease agreement should not serve as a shield for construction violations, nor should a construction violation be used as an excuse to evade the tenant’s rights. Yours sincerely, Adnan Abdullah Al-Othman

Latest news Original source Kuwait's top news today
Link copied ✓