Kuwait Press Memory Latest news
alqabasEconomy By Lawyer Anwar Fahad Al-Zouman

Contract Nullification.. and Unjust Enrichment

Contract Nullification.. and Unjust Enrichment
Alqyas summary

Lawyer Al-Zouman criticizes judicial practice in Kuwait for using the theory of unjust enrichment instead of the automatic effect of contract nullification, which harms the rights of contracting parties due to differences in limitation periods.

Translated by Alqyas from Al-Qabas — Original source

It is well known that the five sources of obligation or right are: “contract, legal ruling, unilateral will, tortious act (which includes the abuse of right), and finally, beneficial act or unjust enrichment.” Consequently, the right to claim compensation and reparation for damages may arise from any of these sources. It may arise due to the rescission of a contract based on contractual liability, the nullity of a contract based on statutory provisions and legal rulings, tortious acts (which include the principle of abuse of right), and finally, beneficial acts or unjust enrichment. Compensation whose source is a legal ruling and which arises from the nullity of a contract is termed “restoring the contracting parties to the state they were in prior to contracting,” which is undoubtedly one form of compensation. Since each of these sources of obligation and right has its own specific legislative framework governing its affairs from its inception, so to speak, until its fulfillment—whether voluntary, specific performance, monetary payment, or extinction by prescription—it is absolutely impermissible to treat any of them as a substitute for, or to allow one to replace another, in filing lawsuits for compensation before courts. Doing so would lead to errors in the application of the law and the unjustified loss of creditors’ legitimate rights.

The point of the foregoing is that in Kuwait, contracting parties involved in judicial disputes, influenced by the precedents established and consolidated by the Court of Cassation, have tended to rely on the principle of “beneficial act or unjust enrichment” to secure compensation and recover their rights, in cases where the court rules that the contract concluded between them is null and void. This is based on the premise that a ruling of nullity renders the contract void ab initio, as if it never existed. This inevitably forces the plaintiff, whether willingly or not, to resort to the theory of beneficial act or unjust enrichment to assert their claims. In my view, this approach is undoubtedly incorrect and unsound, lacks legal justification, and will lead to anomalous and illogical outcomes that undermine justice by causing the loss of legitimate rights, unless this practice is corrected.

This was indeed the reality in one of the cases brought before Kuwaiti courts, which involved a substantial financial claim. The court ruled the contract null and void, compelling the rights-holder, in an attempt to recover their rights, to resort to the cause of beneficial act or unjust enrichment, as is commonly done before the courts. Consequently, the court naturally applied the specific statute of limitations rules governing unjust enrichment, which sets a three-year period for such claims. This could have resulted in the rights-holder losing their case and completely forfeiting their legitimate rights, instead of the court automatically awarding compensation based on the automatic legal effect of the contract’s nullity, namely, restoring the parties to their pre-contractual state. This restoration is mandated by, and explicitly stipulated in, Article 187 of the Civil Code, without even needing to be expressly stated in the operative part of the judgment. In such a case, the right is not extinguished except by the passage of 15 years according to general rules, rather than three years.

Four facts: The claim for compensation through the automatic effect of a ruling declaring a contract null and void, which operates by operation of law, is governed by different legal rules and principles compared to a claim based on beneficial act or unjust enrichment. These are two distinct and dissimilar situations. Therefore, as previously stated, it is absolutely impermissible to apply one as a substitute for, or to allow one to replace the other. Otherwise, justice itself will be the greatest victim.

There is no doubt that the difference and lack of similarity in compensation arising from the legal effect of the nullity of a contract, which stems from statutory provisions, and compensation based on negotiorum gestio or unjust enrichment, is manifested in the following facts:

1. The characteristic of mutuality in the cases of impoverishment and enrichment: This characteristic exists when the contract, whether valid or void, meaning that both parties to the contract impoverished and enriched each other, given that the contract is bilateral by nature, i.e., it consists of two counterparties. In contrast, this characteristic is absent in negotiorum gestio or unjust enrichment, where one party is impoverished while another party is enriched at the expense of the first.

2. The constituting circumstances: Negotiorum gestio presupposes its existence and, according to its traditional principle and concept, arises in the absence of a contract, whether valid or void. It may even occur when the two parties are complete strangers to each other, or even in the absence of the other benefiting party entirely. For example, one party might, for instance, repair a neighbor’s wall during the neighbor’s absence. None of this is conceivable in a contractual relationship, regardless of the validity of the contract.

3. The mechanism for enforcing the compensation claim: Compensation through the legal effect of a ruling declaring nullity occurs automatically by operation of law. In contrast, compensation based on negotiorum gestio or unjust enrichment must be the subject of a judicial claim.

4. The limitation period: There is no specific statutory provision regarding the limitation period for a compensation claim arising from the restitution of the contracting parties to their pre-contractual status pursuant to a ruling declaring the contract null and void. Consequently, such a claim is subject to the general limitation rules, which prescribe a period of 15 years. In contrast, there is a specific statutory provision regarding the limitation period for negotiorum gestio or unjust enrichment, which is three years. Therefore, it is imperative for the relevant parties to correct prevailing practices and approaches in this legal matter, a necessity justified by legal provisions and the requirements of the proper administration of justice.

Attorney Anwar Fahd Al-Zaman

Latest news Original source Kuwait's top news today
Link copied ✓