Trump and the New Congress (1)

Trump's loss of the congressional majority limits his powers and opens a phase of institutional conflict between the President and legislative councils.
Translated by Alqyas from Al-Qabas — Original source
Trump Between the Hammer of the House and the Anvil of the Senate: The U.S. Presidency, Balancing Executive Powers with Legislative and Oversight Authorities
The U.S. midterm elections were not merely a partisan contest for seats in Congress; they represented a shift in the balance of power within American governing institutions. According to announced results, the November 3, 2026 elections saw control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate pass to the Democratic Party, signaling a new phase of divided government as the new Congress convenes in January. This raises the question: Can President Donald Trump govern effectively now that legislative and oversight powers are in the hands of his opponents? Or does the loss of majority status signify a shift in the political center of gravity from the White House to Capitol Hill? The answer lies not solely in partisan calculations, but in understanding the philosophy of power distribution, reading the balance of forces, and anticipating the trajectory of institutional conflict.
First: The U.S. Constitution – Restricting Power and Preventing Monopoly
The U.S. Constitution established a system based on the separation of powers: Article I vested legislative authority in Congress, Article II in the President, and Article III in the federal judiciary. This distribution is not merely an administrative arrangement, but a safeguard against the monopolization of decision-making. From the perspective of legitimate politics, this value aligns with the objective of restricting power through justice and the public interest, preventing tyranny and autocracy. The Almighty said: “Indeed, Allah commands you to render trusts to whom they are due and when you judge between people to judge with justice” (Quran, 4:58). The intention is not to equate the two systems, but to invoke the shared political value of holding power accountable and regulating its exercise.
Second: The President – Executive Power and Limits of Will
The President possesses broad powers: as head of state and government, and commander-in-chief of the armed forces, he oversees the implementation of laws, manages federal agencies, appoints senior officials, judges, and ambassadors, and negotiates treaties in accordance with constitutional procedures. He also has the authority to issue executive orders, but these do not equate to legislation and cannot contradict existing laws. Here lies Trump’s dilemma: he retains the tools of execution, diplomacy, and the veto, but loses the supportive legislative environment. From a pragmatic perspective, it is clear that the President’s continued powers do not mean he retains his previous freedom of action; power is one thing, and the ability to deploy it and translate it into stable policies is another.
Third: The House of Representatives – Legislation, Oversight, and Accountability
The House of Representatives holds constitutional precedence in introducing revenue and tax bills, while the Senate participates in approving budgets and financial appropriations. Furthermore, its committees, under established rules and mandates, can summon officials and documents, hold investigative hearings, and take testimony. The House alone has the power to initiate impeachment proceedings, though it cannot remove the President from office on its own. Thus, the Democratic majority becomes a tool for oversight and political pressure, potentially keeping the White House administration preoccupied with defending its decisions as much as with implementing its agenda.
Fourth: The Senate – Keys to Appointments and Filibuster
The Senate holds the power to confirm presidential appointments of senior officials, judges, and ambassadors, as well as international treaties, by a two-thirds majority of those present. A simple majority suffices for the final vote on most appointments, giving Democrats the ability to reject Trump’s nominees or block their confirmation. Legislatively, the Senate filibuster rule requires 60 votes to end debate on most legislation, with certain procedural exceptions.
In cases of impeachment, the Council presides over the trial, and a conviction leading to the removal of the President requires a two-thirds majority of the members present. Fifth: Instruments of Confrontation.. The Jurisprudence of Balance and Interests Confrontation is embodied in three instruments: the presidential veto, which Congress can override with a two-thirds majority in both chambers; government funding, which cannot be spent without legislative appropriations; and impeachment, the procedures for which are distributed between the two chambers. A failure to reach financial consensus may lead to a government shutdown, affecting public services and facilities. Here, the importance of the jurisprudence of balancing interests and harms becomes evident; not everything the President can implement necessarily serves the public interest, nor does everything the parliamentary majority can block necessarily serve the public interest. The criterion is preserving the stability of the state and the interests of society, and preventing partisan competition from paralyzing institutions. Sixth: Foreign Policy.. The Jurisprudence of Power and Interests The conflict is not confined to domestic affairs; the President commands the armed forces, while Congress holds the power to declare war, approve military funding, and regulate the armed forces, in addition to legislative and oversight tools. The War Powers Resolution of 1973 imposed procedural constraints on the President’s unilateral conduct of military operations. From the perspective of the jurisprudence of power, American influence does not rest solely on military strength, but on the integration of political, economic, diplomatic, and military instruments. From the perspective of the jurisprudence of interests, we must consider the impact of domestic divisions on foreign commitments, alliances, and regional crises, particularly the files concerning Iran, Gulf security, and relations with Israel—topics to which we will devote specialized articles in this series. The Supreme Court and the federal judiciary remain an independent branch in adjudicating constitutional disputes and defining the boundaries of the powers of governing institutions. In conclusion, Trump’s loss of the congressional majority does not strip him of the legitimacy of the presidency, nor does it deprive him of his executive powers, but it does constrain his ability to translate his political will into stable legislation and policies. The issue is not who holds power alone, but how it is distributed, how it is checked, and what the interests are in its deployment. This is Trump’s real battle with the new Congress. The Essence 1. Restricting Power: The distribution of competencies is a guarantee against monopolizing decision-making and achieving the public interest. 2. Limits of the Presidency: Trump retains executive powers and the veto, but loses the supporting legislative majority. 3. Strength of the House: The Chamber possesses tools for investigation, oversight, financial initiative, and initiating impeachment charges. 4. Keys of the Senate: The Chamber holds the power to confirm appointments, ratify treaties, and try impeached officials. 5. Jurisprudence of Balance: The public interest is not achieved merely by the victory of the President or the opposition, but by prioritizing state stability over partisan attrition. 6. Jurisprudence of Interests: The effects of domestic conflict may extend beyond Washington to international policy, Gulf security, and Middle Eastern balances. Dr. Abdulhamid Khalifa Al-Shaiji