Byzantine stagnation
The text criticizes intellectual stagnation and blind imitation resulting from reliance on binary logic.
Translated by Alqyas from Al-Nahar — Original source
It is said that a certain individual married and had a son, whom he named after his father; the father had been named after his grandfather, and the grandfather after his great-grandfather, and so on, without any unique, distinct name ever breaking through this chain of nominal duplication. As that son grows up, he learns letters and words, and is then taught that 1 + 1 equals 2. Moreover, all his life experiences are framed in binary terms: right or wrong, permissible or impermissible, tea or coffee, for example. Thus, as he matures, the Aristotelian notion of logic takes root within him, with no third or fourth option ever considered in his reasoning. Consequently, that poor soul lives in the fallacy of false dichotomy, a well-known error in logic, without even realizing it.
How can we trust the judgment of such an individual—whose reasoning is confined to this rigid binary logic—to evaluate historical or political figures, or to make pivotal decisions, when his syllogistic reasoning is fundamentally flawed? How many such human archetypes, over the course of years, have written history, shaped political and social stances, and issued decrees that affected both the near and the far? This phenomenon applies not only to the leadership of social movements but also to narrower social circles, such as the family and friends. These are questions that may spark skeptical reflections, prompting us to re-examine what we have absorbed, learned, and read from our ancestors.
The flaw in rational deduction, when it fails to follow a proper methodology, has created intellectual stagnation that has affected not only civilizational progress and development, but also taste and personal grooming. As a result, we end up producing a repetitive copy of others’ thoughts, opinions, and even clothing. Because logic restricted to only two mutually exclusive options inevitably leads to logical fallacies in reasoning, and because such reasoning is impaired, the shortest path to knowledge becomes merely repeating what those who came before us said. Every idea or opinion we repeat is the product of conclusions drawn by predecessors, without examination, scrutiny, or critique. Every stance we encounter is met with either opposition or support, with no third or fourth perspective considered. Every garment we wear and every food we consume becomes an unquestioned assumption, without understanding why it exists in that particular form, and so on.
Eventually, we become a society that repeats rather than innovates, imitates rather than creates, and answers with “yes” or “no” and nothing else, operating with an ethnic or tribal mindset devoid of individuality or alternative expressions. We are filled with arrogance regarding our life and historical conclusions, not because they are the best, but simply because we found them as they are. It is like someone who has eaten white cheese for fifty years and swears it is the most delicious cheese in existence, not because it truly is the best, but simply because he has never tried any other kind.