Stability of the Law... When Trust Becomes a Guarantee for the Future
A dialogue on the importance of the stability of legal legislation to attract investment and maintain investor confidence
Translated by Alqyas from Al-Nahar — Original source
In one of my conversations with Saqr, after we had finished discussing the role of law in attracting investment, he returned to the topic with a question that seemed a natural extension of our discussion. Saqr said: “We have talked a lot about the importance of law in encouraging investors to enter the market, but I have another question: What happens if an investor enters the market feeling confident in the laws, only to be surprised later by legislative changes that were not in his calculations?” I replied: “Here we reach a stage more important than merely attracting investment, which is preserving investor confidence after he has invested his money and started his project.” Saqr asked: “Isn’t it the state’s right to develop its laws and amend legislation in line with its economic and social interests?” I said: “Certainly. The law is not a rigid text, and the state cannot remain hostage to legislation that has been overtaken by time. But there is a significant difference between developing the law and changing rules in a way that deprives investors of the ability to predict what lies ahead.” Saqr asked: “And how can that affect investors?” I said: “Imagine a foreign investor who decides to establish a major real estate project. He studies the laws, obtains the necessary approvals, spends his money, concludes contracts, and structures his financial obligations based on clear legal rules. Then, legislative changes occur that disrupt his legal position or affect his rights and obligations. Don’t you think that would make him reconsider before expanding his investments?” Saqr replied: “It may even make him hesitate to continue, and perhaps transfer his funds to another country.” I said: “That is the essence of the matter. An investor does not look at the law only when entering the market, but also at whether he can rely on it throughout the duration of his project. Investment, by its nature, is not an instantaneous decision; it is a financial and economic commitment that may extend over many years.” Saqr said: “So you believe that legislative stability is no less important than its attractiveness?” I replied: “Indeed, the attractiveness of the law may lose its value if stability is absent. It is not enough for the state to grant investors benefits and facilitations at the outset, then leave them facing an unclear legislative future. Investors need to know their rights, the limits of their obligations, and the safeguards that protect their legal position.” Saqr asked: “Is this issue limited to laws governing real estate and investment?” I said: “No, the matter is much broader. There are laws on property, labor, taxation, licensing, competition, intellectual property, and other legislation that intersect with the life of an economic project. An investor may not be directly concerned with a specific sector, but he is affected by other laws that regulate the environment in which he operates.” Saqr said: “But protecting investors does not mean granting them immunity from new laws, does it?” I replied: “Well said, Saqr. This is a crucial point that we must not overlook. Legal stability does not mean freezing legislation or granting investors privileges at the expense of the public interest. The state has the right to regulate its economy, protect its society, and review its policies, but it must ensure clarity, fairness, and gradualism in change, and respect rights and legal positions that have arisen legitimately.” Saqr said: “It seems the problem is not with amending the law per se, but with the manner of amendment and its effects.” I said: “That is correct. Good legislation is measured not only by the objectives it achieves upon enactment, but also by the clarity of its effects, its feasibility of implementation, and its coherence with the rest of the legal system. When rules change without adequate study or organized transition, it can create legal disputes and undermine confidence in the market.”
Saqer asked: Can we say that legal stability has become part of the competition among countries to attract investment? I replied: Absolutely. Today, countries do not compete solely based on their natural resources, commercial opportunities, or geographic location; they also compete on their ability to provide a reliable legal environment. An investor may find opportunities in many places, but it is not easy to find everywhere a clear legislative framework, a judiciary that protects rights, and stable procedures whose outcomes can be predicted. Saqer paused for a moment, then said: So we are not talking about a law that protects only the investor, but about a law that safeguards trust between the state and all those who deal with it. I told him: That is precisely the point I wanted to make. Legal stability does not serve only the foreign investor; it also serves the domestic investor, the small business owner, the worker, the consumer, and anyone whose activities are linked to the economic life. When everyone feels that rights are not subject to whims and that obligations are governed by known rules, the economic environment becomes more secure and better able to grow. Saqer said: Now I understand why it is not enough to draft good laws; we must also manage and develop them effectively. I replied: Yes, Saqer. A strong state is not one that issues many laws, but one that selects them wisely, ensures their coherence, maintains their stability, and develops them without undermining the trust it has built. The law may open the door to investment, but its stability is what enables investors to move forward with confidence. Source: The book “Legal Stability and Its Role in Attracting Foreign Investment” by Prof. Dr. Bashar Adnan Malakawi, who holds a PhD in Civil Law, a Master’s in Economic Private Law, and a Master’s in Public Law from France.