Opinion: Venice and Historical Heritage in Souq Al-Mubarakiya

A book links the fall of Venice to elite dominance and the closing of economic opportunities
Translated by Alqyas from Al-Jarida — Original source
The book Why Nations Fail, or “Why Nations Fail,” presents a precise historical narrative of the reasons behind the collapse that often befalls nations after a period of economic prosperity and stability. It shows readers that, despite differences in countries and eras, the causes are largely similar, enabling those interested to identify nations on the verge of collapse.
In 810 CE, the city of Venice, or “La Serenissima,” was among the wealthiest regions in the world, thanks to its advanced economic systems and geographic location, which made it the most important international trade route linking Europe, Asia, and Africa. Its rise began with what is known as the commenda contract. This was a partnership between two parties: a resident investor who contributed capital, and a traveling merchant who invested the capital in a single maritime commercial voyage. At the end of the venture, the merchant kept 25 percent of the profits and returned the investor’s capital along with the remaining profits. This system supported the wealthy while giving ambitious and enterprising individuals the opportunity to improve their living standards and create a strong economy and new wealth.
The Doge of Venice, titled “Doge,” was chosen by the “Supreme Council,” which was controlled by an elite of wealthy families, to serve for life. The Doge’s role in supporting commenda contracts and other arrangements designed to encourage development contributed to sustaining the growth and prosperity achieved for decades. However, this did not protect the economy from “creative destruction,” embraced by the sons and grandsons of wealthy families who viewed newly rich individuals as direct economic and political challenges to their status in the state. They demanded restrictions on these newcomers’ activities to limit their competitiveness, while simultaneously curbing the Doge’s powers.
The economic decline of Venice began in the 13th century with the issuance of the Golden Book, an official register of Venetian nobility, and changes to the rules for selecting members of the Supreme Council. New nominations for council membership became impossible, and the use of commenda contracts was banned—contracts that had been among the key innovations that made Venice wealthy. Council members thus transformed into a hereditary aristocratic class whose primary concern was no longer economic development.
Those outside the noble class did not allow their influence to erode without resistance. Political tensions escalated, and economic activity in Venice became confined to tourism and fishing. Instead of leading trade routes, Venetians today make pizza and ice cream and craft colored glass blown for foreign tourists.
Economies advance when new ideas, technologies, and institutions replace old ones that have lost their capacity for production and development. They collapse when monopolies prevail through specialized but unqualified institutions.