Kuwait Press Memory Latest news
aljaridaOpinion By Ahmad Yaqoub Baqer

Winds and stakes: when disagreement over car wrapping exceeds its legitimate bounds

Winds and stakes: when disagreement over car wrapping exceeds its legitimate bounds
Alqyas summary

Divergent legal opinions on car wrapping with criticism of personal attack methods

Translated by Alqyas from Al-Jarida — Original source

I interviewed many brothers, scholars of Sharia and specialists in the issue of car impounding, which is carried out by owners who drive in a manner that endangers people’s lives. I found that legal opinions and jurisprudential rulings vary between permissibility and prohibition. That is, some permit punishing and deterring violators by impounding their vehicles, while others prohibit impounding, arguing that it constitutes the destruction of property that could be utilized, and that violators should instead be deterred through other means. Each opinion has its own evidence and arguments, and both approaches necessitate disciplining the offender. There is no Islamic ruling that mandates the compulsory impounding and destruction of vehicles. I do not intend in this article to side with either opinion. It has become clear to me that these views are not new; they have existed in Islamic jurisprudence for a long time and are not innovations introduced by those who issued fatwas prohibiting impounding. Nor is this view exclusive to any specific scholar, such as Dr. Fulan or Ullan. Nevertheless, some individuals launched an unjustified attack on those who issued fatwas prohibiting impounding, insulting them and questioning their loyalty to the country. This occurred despite the fact that the Kuwaiti Constitution guarantees freedom of opinion. These jurists have the right to express their views on various laws and decisions, provided their opinions remain within the framework of Sharia and the law. The insults did not stop at those who issued fatwas prohibiting impounding; some went further to generalize their attacks, insulting all Islamic orientations and inciting against them. How did these insulters reach such a low level of disrespect, extending their abuse to others? They could have simply responded to those who opposed impounding, clarified their positions, and presented their arguments. Did they not realize that attacking, belittling, and ridiculing opposing views, as well as intimidating their proponents on social media, contradicts Sharia? This approach contributed to the exclusion of many sound opinions from the work of the previous National Assembly, leading to legislative and economic errors. Such opinions should have been discussed respectfully, scientifically, and without agitation or personal attacks.

With the advent of modern social media and anonymous accounts, we have witnessed a deviation from debating in the best manner. Vices of the tongue have become prevalent in dialogue. I also found that the core of the disagreement concerns the most effective deterrent methods that serve the public interest under Sharia: Is it vehicle impounding, confiscation, imprisonment, or fines? This disagreement deserves study by social and psychological specialists. One supporter of impounding told me that confiscation, imprisonment, and fines have not deterred these reckless youths, while another believes that confiscating and selling the vehicle is more effective, as the owner will see his property become someone else’s.

Currently, new legislation should follow a path that leads to further scrutiny and submission to the Fatwa Committee at the Ministry of Awqaf (Endowments), and open the floor for all specialists to express their opinions before enactment. This would ensure broad participation, higher quality laws, and protection from errors.

Latest news Original source Kuwait's top news today
Link copied ✓