Opinion: Annual Distributions and What Is Not Said About Them in Company Statements

The article discusses contradictions in financial distribution decisions and emphasizes the importance of transparency in budgets.
Translated by Alqyas from Al-Jarida — Original source
As the year draws to a close, most boards of directors will approve next year’s budget. However, few will realize that this very approval will determine whether next year’s dividends are even feasible. Although dividend recommendations will be issued alongside annual results at the beginning of the year and are likely to be ratified by the general assembly in the second quarter, appearing as if they were decided at that time, they are not. While dividends are paid from next year’s cash, that cash is committed now: to capital expenditure, bank facilities, and working capital required by the business plan. What remains after all these commitments is the dividend the company can pay without borrowing. If no one pays attention to this item, the dividend is determined by default, not by decision.
Reviewing our markets in past years allows us to classify dividends into two categories. The first category has a verifiable source and a predictable trajectory; the cash source is the company’s operations after capital expenditure and debt service, and the board has disclosed and committed to this year after year. There is no harm if the amount changes from year to year, being generous or modest depending on the company’s results, without surprising anyone, as investors could derive the dividend figures from the financial statements before the board’s announcement. In this regard, some companies may adopt a policy of a small fixed dividend supplemented by a variable portion based on results, but this formula is too complex for markets to read effectively.
The second category sees dividends decided anew each year, rising and falling for reasons known to the board but unknown to the markets. Worse still, these decisions are sometimes accompanied by other capital decisions that contradict them. We occasionally see a company announce a cash dividend, followed by a capital increase, and then additional borrowing, all within a single year, while its major project is still under construction. If each decision is viewed in isolation, it may have its own logic, but taken together, these decisions convey to the markets something the company did not intend. Cash dividends might be paid to keep the share price strong during the capital increase offer, which then requires shareholders to reinvest that cash at a subsidized price, followed by borrowing to cover what the increase did not, all to finance a project that has not yet begun to generate revenue. Although markets may not react sharply to decisions that may contradict each other, the reality is that markets will be unable to form a unified reading of the nature of these dividends.
The difference here is not in the size of the dividends or the tools used, as dividends, capital increases, and bank facilities are all legitimate instruments. Rather, the difference lies in the company’s ability to state in a single sentence where the cash came from, why the company did not need it, and why the subsequent decision does not contradict the preceding one.
Some may argue that stock prices rarely reflect such realities, as prices often remain at stable levels, sometimes for years. However, the question is not about the stock’s current price level, but rather what its price would have been in the absence of any price support. A company whose capital decisions are internally inconsistent finds itself needing to support its share price, either by buying back treasury shares, by a major shareholder absorbing shares that others do not want, or by maintaining a dividend payout to keep the stock within the universe of yield-oriented equities. None of this violates regulatory rules, but each approach entails a cost borne either from the company’s cash or from the major shareholder’s pocket, with minority shareholders also bearing their share of the burden without being consulted. Markets evaluate the entire capital narrative, and price support does not alter that valuation; it merely determines who bears the difference.
I am almost certain that no board member has failed to sit through a meeting where this burden is manufactured: the dividend line item is carried forward from the previous year’s budget unchanged, because any reduction would be read by the market in an undesirable manner, and because cash is unavailable, a bank facility is drawn or an asset is sold. Twelve months later, interest expenses have risen and the asset has been sold, yet dividends are not even mentioned in that discussion, despite being the root cause.
Another common error, frequently made by many companies and misread by investors, occurs when a company announces a 10 percent cash dividend and a 5 percent bonus share issue, which investors collectively interpret as 15 percent, when in reality it is only 10 percent. Bonus shares merely represent a transfer of retained earnings to paid-up capital; the company pays nothing, and each shareholder simply owns the same percentage of the same company the following day. What the board has actually decided is to retain these funds permanently within the company—a financing decision that carries the implicit promise that the retained capital will generate a higher return inside the company than the shareholder could have achieved outside it. The subsequent price increase prices in this promise, and annual results are what hold the company accountable for it. The following year, the same 10 percent payout applies to a larger number of shares, meaning more cash under the same headline. This does not make bonus shares inherently wrong; the error lies in presenting a financing decision as a reward.
Building budgets today requires adopting the correct sequence, which is the reverse of the conventional approach: it starts with the cash that operations will generate, not with the profit to be announced. From this, committed capital expenditures, debt repayments, and working capital requirements outlined in the business plan are deducted. The remainder represents cash for which the company has no better use, and this constitutes the cash dividend that the budget can sustain. If this amount is lower than last year’s dividend, the annual report should state this in a single paragraph. If the company retains capital instead of distributing it, that same paragraph should explain what return this retained capital will generate.
The first type of company can write that paragraph; the second cannot. Markets price the difference between the two.
* Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA), co-founder of Ethica Financial Advisory. Held senior executive positions at several leading Kuwaiti companies and served on the boards of numerous companies across the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) states.