Kuwait Press Memory Latest news
aljaridaOpinion By Badour Al-Mutairi

Don't applaud me

Don't applaud me
Alqyas summary

The text discusses the impact of flattery on autonomy and emphasizes the importance of accepting criticism to avoid mistakes, citing the wisdom of Umar ibn al-Khattab.

Translated by Alqyas from Al-Jarida — Original source

Not all praise elevates us; some merely comforts us, pats us on the back, and flatters us by confirming we are right, before quietly closing the door on a small question: What if our idea is flawed?

Perhaps this is why our expressions change when someone says, “But…” after we finish speaking. We begin preparing our rebuttal before hearing the rest. When we become accustomed to the approval of those around us, we learn to confuse their courtesy toward our idea with its correctness.

Once we habituate this confusion, criticism becomes heavier than it deserves. We no longer hear it as a remark on what we said, but rather as a judgment against us. We defend not only the idea, but also the enthusiasm we invested in it, and the self-image we constructed while watching it succeed—as if retracting it means retracting a part of ourselves.

The soul has its tricks to protect what it loves. The critic, we tell ourselves, doesn’t understand, or perhaps they are jealous, or they are among those who dislike everything. Indeed, the most dangerous thing one can do to one’s life is to deceive oneself. This deception may begin when we see ourselves as always right, assuming that those who disagree are less understanding or knowledgeable. We then interpret their criticism as envy, closing the door to the possibility that they may have seen what escaped us.

The hardest question remains: Do I reject their opinion because it is unfair, or because I cannot bear the possibility that they might be more right than I am?

Not all criticism is justified, nor is all praise mere flattery. Some remarks are delivered harshly, and others aim to belittle the recipient. But we will never know the difference if we refuse to listen before hearing the full message. We need to give the other party the opportunity to finish speaking, then consider the substance of their comment and examine it before judging their intent or objecting to it.

We may not realize the value of a remark until later, when we discover that a small flaw could have been addressed early, but a single word allowed it to grow until its correction became costly. Whenever those around us feel that honesty with us comes at a high price, they choose silence, and their observations remain trapped.

Umar ibn al-Khattab, may Allah be pleased with him, said: “May Allah have mercy on a person who pointed out my flaws to me.” Whoever is unable to accept this gift may remain surrounded by applause, yet alone… in the face of their mistakes.

Apologies to everyone who contacted me and did not receive a reply due to a malfunction in my previous email address. You can now reach me at: [email protected]

Latest news Original source Kuwait's top news today
Link copied ✓