Kuwait Press Memory Latest news
aljaridaOpinion By Mohammad Al-Jarallah

The fall of 'selective feminism'

The fall of 'selective feminism'
Alqyas summary

Criticism of the selectivity of Western feminist discourse compared to women's issues in conflict zones and cultural conflicts in Egypt.

Translated by Alqyas from Al-Jarida — Original source

In Western political and human rights discourse, women’s empowerment and their access to leadership positions are presented as benchmarks of societal progress, alongside their absolute freedom, unencumbered by religious or familial social customs—an issue worthy of attention. The former Prime Minister of Finland, Sanna Marin, has emerged as a symbol of this progress, alongside leaders such as Jacinda Ardern in New Zealand (the Prime Minister who breastfed her child in parliament)! Yet the paradox that strikes me is the speed with which media mobilization defends a woman at the pinnacle of power, compared to the level of attention afforded to women in Gaza, which is disproportionate to the scale of their suffering. In both cases, women’s dignity should be the central issue.

When Sanna Marin assumed the office of Prime Minister of Finland in 2019, she was 34 years old, becoming at the time the youngest head of government in the world. She led a coalition whose parties were headed by women under the age of 40, making her rise appear to many as evidence that the “glass ceiling” hindering women’s access to decision-making positions could be overcome.

In the summer of 2022, videos surfaced showing her dancing and singing at a private party, sparking a major controversy in Finland. Critics accused her of irresponsibility, while unprecedented solidarity campaigns emerged across Europe and America, viewing the attack on her as a double standard and an intrusion into her private life. Defending her right to privacy was understandable. What deserves discussion, however, is how such immense energy is mobilized for the cause of a woman who already enjoys a global platform, and why this energy dissipates when women are far from circles of influence, as in Gaza and Sudan.

In Gaza, a woman searches for a safe place to give birth, while another mother tries to find her children under the rubble. In Sudan, a survivor of sexual violence attempts to access medical treatment, while local women’s organizations lose part of their funding. These women have advocates who document their suffering and defend them, but what share of attention do their causes receive from major platforms when headlines fade? Who remains beside the survivor in Gaza and Sudan after the journalist leaves?

This is the core of the objection to the selectivity of some human rights discourse. In Helsinki, the question concerned the boundary between public responsibility and private life; in Gaza, it concerns women’s right to life, their right to give birth safely, and their right to find shelter for their children. If the Helsinki case crossed borders within days, we have the right to ask about the ability of women in Gaza and Sudan to keep their issues present in public discourse.

Turning to East Asia, we find demands with clear impacts on women’s lives. In Japan, issues such as narrowing the wage gap and allowing both spouses to retain their family names after marriage are raised. In China, it is a natural demand that jobs be open to women based on merit and that they have opportunities for promotion. In Russia, protecting women from domestic violence remains a fundamental demand in the absence of specific legislation. These are issues that defenders of women are expected to place at the heart of their work, and women can see their impact in their salaries, employment opportunities, and safety within the home.

In Europe and America, feminist campaigns, with their resources, platforms, and mobilization capacity, push the debate beyond merely alleviating injustice against women. Instead, they advocate for absolute freedom without constraints. When family obligations are portrayed as burdens in themselves, and religious and social values are treated as obstacles to freedom, this discourse becomes a tool for undermining the family bond, upon which social cohesion and state stability depend.

In our homes, there are values that “feminists” do not understand, such as the importance of maintaining family ties and what that bond means when a father falls ill, when one of the children faces financial hardship, or when a mother needs someone to share her burdens. Integral to honoring these values is ensuring that women find fairness and security within their homes, with each party fulfilling its obligations toward the other.

Speaking of double standards, I can only smile with pride as I recall a scene from the Red Sea Film Festival in fraternal Egypt. On the red carpet, some dresses seemed to compete in revealing the body. As soon as advisor Murtada Mansour criticized the excessive exposure in the actresses’ attire, Ilham Shahin rose to defend them, sharply condemning his tone. Mansour responded with an even sharper tone, and the verbal clash escalated until it moved from television screens and social media to a formal complaint filed by Shahin with the Supreme Council for Media Regulation.

Amid this media spat, the “teacher,” the advisor, spoke in his beautiful and straightforward Egyptian accent, voicing what is often discussed in many household gatherings. He sees himself as a defender of authentic Arab and Islamic values, insisting that modesty and decency have a place that must remain in our public life. It is as if his words echoed the famous couplets of Imam al-Shafi’i:

I consider the advisor sincere in his defense of these values, and in those couplets lies the truth of the majority of people and our honesty with ourselves. A person may recognize his own shortcomings, yet he remains supportive of those who promote goodness, righteousness, and da’wah, and of anyone who defends the values on which he was raised, whether from a mosque pulpit, a media platform, a political party, an organization, or the political arena. This is the case for many in our Arab and Islamic societies. Indeed, the novelty of the “teacher” is that he brought to the screen, in the manner familiar to Egyptians, the very words that many utter around the family dining table.

Latest news Original source Kuwait's top news today
Link copied ✓