In the Spotlight: Development or Hoarding and Monopoly?

Al-Arabi Club proposes participation of reserve teams in the First Division, but the text criticizes the gap between the Spanish model and the Kuwaiti reality
Translated by Alqyas from Al-Jarida — Original source
I do not know why, whenever we face a problem in Kuwaiti football, some people rush to import solutions from abroad, as if merely replicating a European or foreign experience is sufficient to repair the damage caused by years of confusion and negligence!
Al-Arabi Club submitted a proposal to the Kuwait Football Association, requesting that Premier League clubs be allowed to participate with their reserve teams in the First Division, similar to practices in many European competitions, most notably the Spanish league. They justified this by citing the technical and competitive gap between youth categories and the first team, and the potential loss of talents and players as a result.
However, the comparison with Spain, which may look appealing on paper, overlooks fundamental differences in the nature of professionalism and club operations. There, players are fully professional, and clubs manage their reserve teams within an integrated system. Some even sign foreign players to bolster these reserves and may call them up to the first team when needed, without registering them in the official squad, thereby giving them opportunities to compete and develop. In our context, the objective seems somewhat different. A player who fails to secure playing time with the first team, instead of seeking another club that offers him a chance to prove his abilities and improve his level, may find himself tied to his current club’s registration, unable to transfer and benefit from his productive years. Now, the reserve league proposal arrives to provide the club with an additional station to retain him, under the guise of development and talent creation, while the actual outcome may be keeping the player confined to the club, waiting for an opportunity that may never come, and in the process, losing chances that could have shaped his future.
Even more strangely, the Spanish model does not rely on keeping every talent in the reserve team indefinitely. There are players who have moved directly from youth categories to the first team thanks to their abilities. Lamine Yamal, and before him Messi and others, are prime examples. This clearly demonstrates that true talent does not require years of waiting, but rather discovery and the right opportunity at the right time. In our case, a player may remain on the bench, then move to the reserve team to continue waiting, before the club finally gives him a chance to appear with the first team at the age of 23 or 24, presenting him to the public as an emerging player and a promising talent. It seems that our concept of an “emerging player” is linked less to age and more to the number of years spent waiting.
Perhaps the greatest irony is that Al-Arabi Club, which, like many other clubs, suffers from countless financial and administrative crises in its first team—whether involving local players or foreign professionals—wants to create a team that is administratively and financially independent. It is as if the club lacks nothing more than adding a new bill to its list of obligations. Instead of seeking ways to address and resolve existing crises, it appears to want to open another door to new problems through this proposal, as if clubs need more burdens rather than solutions that alleviate them.
We want to become like Spain, but in our own way; we adopt the reserve league, but abandon professionalism; we import the system, but forget its conditions for success... And in the end, we may discover that talent now owns a reserve team, a longer waiting bench, and an additional financial crisis!