Translators and academics at Sharjah International Book Fair: AI does not replace literary translators
&cropxunits=450&cropyunits=300&w=770)
Translators and academics at Sharjah emphasized that AI is a supportive tool and does not eliminate human responsibility in literary translation.
Translated by Alqyas from Al-Anba — Original source
Sharjah – Yousef Ghanem: Translators, academics, and publishers have affirmed that the ability of digital tools to convey meanings and produce texts rapidly does not negate the translator’s role in understanding the aesthetic and cultural dimensions of creative works, nor their responsibility for translation accuracy and preserving the specificity of the original text.
This was stated during the seminar “Why Translate in the Digital Age? – Tarjman Prize Seminar,” held as part of the 45th edition of the Sharjah International Book Fair 2026, which focused on “The Future of Literary Translation in the Era of Artificial Intelligence Advancements.”
The seminar addressed opportunities for leveraging artificial intelligence in translators’ work, challenges facing the translation of less widely spoken languages, the impact of modern technologies on the publishing market, the need for transparency in disclosing AI use, and the protection of translators’ and readers’ rights. Participants included Dr. Isabella Camara Dávila, Dr. Subhi Bustani, Dr. Luis Miguel Cienfuegos, Dr. Kim Young-woo, and Dr. Valeria Macías Pages.
Translation and Meaning Transfer: Dr. Subhi Bustani outlined the differences between human and machine translation of poetic texts, citing excerpts from Mahmoud Darwish’s poems and their French translation by translator and critic Elias Sanbar. He clarified that while machine translation can convey meaning according to the rules of the target language, it may cause the text to lose some of its aesthetic and rhythmic qualities.
He cited the repetition of the letter “waw” in Mahmoud Darwish’s poetry, which gives the verses a rapid rhythm and expresses the succession and accumulation of events, whereas the digital translation omitted this repetition in line with standard French phrasing conventions. He also focused on the phrase “so that we may end” in one of Darwish’s poems, explaining that it carries connotations of annihilation and self-termination, while the machine translation interpreted it as the act of finishing writing. He further compared Adonis’s translation of the French poet Yves Bonnefoy’s poem “Against Plato” with its digital translation, considering Adonis’s version to embody the concept of “creative translation,” which reproduces the text through the translator’s spirit and poetic vision, highlighting the creative value added by human translation.
On his part, Dr. Kim Nyung-woo spoke about his 30-year experience in translating Arabic literature into Korean, noting that he is currently using artificial intelligence to translate the book “Al-Nawadir Al-Sultaniyya wa Al-Mahasin Al-Yusufiyya” by Qadi Baha’ al-Din ibn Shaddad, which covers the biography of Sultan Saladin al-Ayyubi. He expects to complete the translation next year, explaining that he employs the technology in three areas: understanding historical contexts and archaic terminology, identifying names of weapons, cities, and figures associated with the Crusades, and selecting Korean vocabulary and refining phrasing. He cited his use of AI to understand the description of a siege engine known as the “tank,” before seeing a miniature model of it during his visit to the Sharjah Museum of Islamic Civilization last October. He emphasized that he treats AI responses as preliminary indicators that require verification by consulting dictionaries and scientific references, stressing that literary translation is a human, intellectual, and spiritual practice that demands cultural knowledge and aesthetic appreciation, while digital technologies remain supportive tools.
On her part, Dr. Isabella Camara Dalfetto affirmed that translating Arabic literature enables Western readers to become familiar with the history and social and cultural experiences of Arab societies. She noted that the translator’s responsibility extends beyond conveying words to include selecting works that help build a deeper understanding of other cultures. She cited translations of works by Ghassan Kanafani and Sahar Khalifeh, which address issues of land loss, displacement, exile, and attachment to memory and identity through individual and family experiences, alongside works by Abdulrahman Munif, Saadallah Wannous, and Sinan Antoon, which reveal aspects of Arab political and social history.
For her part, Dr. Valeria Macias Pages clarified that the development of artificial intelligence requires literary translators to combine deep linguistic and cultural knowledge with the ability to use digital tools. She pointed out that literary translation requires years of reading, study, research, and interaction with different cultures, while AI tools face difficulties in handling less widely spoken languages due to the limited texts and data used to train their models, which affects their ability to perceive nuances and produce accurate translations. She also addressed other challenges related to translating gender issues and ethnic topics, given the gap between societal transformations and the content available digitally.
Regarding transparency and translators’ rights, Dr. Luis Miguel Cienfuegos examined the impact of artificial intelligence on translation as a creative activity, a profession, and a commercial product, warning that the ability to produce and translate large volumes of text at unprecedented speeds may lead to prioritizing the economic value of books over their intellectual and cultural worth.
He pointed to concerns that some publishers are becoming less willing to pay extra for high-quality translations, and to the emergence of translated works that do not name their translators or clarify their responsibility for the content, considering that publishing houses’ decisions will have a significant impact on the future of the profession. He cited data presented during the symposium indicating that Amazon published approximately 10 million e-books between 2020 and 2025, and that 30% of works written with artificial intelligence in the Infinity Library database belong to the romance genre. Kenaida called for regulating the translation market, requiring publishers to disclose their translation methods and the extent of AI usage, and for placing clear labels on book covers that distinguish human translation from machine-generated translation, alongside raising readers’ awareness of their right to receive quality translations. He emphasized that artificial intelligence can be a useful tool for translators, provided there is clarity regarding the limits of its use and that human responsibility continues to guide the translation process and review its outcomes.